Remember, Remember the Fifth of November: Liberty, Faith, and the Price of Justice
“Remember, remember the fifth of November, the gunpowder treason and plot.”
Those words, recited by V in V for Vendetta, have become associated with the Guy Fawkes mask and resistance to authoritarian government. But when I think about November 5, I think about something greater than rebellion against political power. I think about the freedom of individuals to exist within society without surrendering their minds, their beliefs, or their identities to the political and religious ideologies of those who govern them.
I consider myself a classical liberal with conservative constitutional foundations. I believe in individual liberty, smaller government, and laws that apply to everyone. But smaller government, to me, is not necessarily a government with fewer responsibilities or institutions. It is a government that does not overreach, that understands its responsibility to protect the people without attempting to control every aspect of their lives. And that leads me to a question that has become increasingly important in my understanding of November 5: What happens when religious and political authority become so closely connected that the beliefs of one group begin determining the freedoms of everyone else?
November 5, 1605: The History Behind the Mask
The Gunpowder Plot took place in England during a period when religious identity and political authority were deeply intertwined. England had experienced decades of conflict between Catholics and Protestants, and Catholics faced restrictions affecting their worship and participation in society. When James I became king in 1603, some Catholics hoped conditions would improve, but those expectations were not fulfilled.
In 1604, Robert Catesby began organizing a conspiracy to destroy Parliament and kill the king during its ceremonial opening. Guy Fawkes became involved in the plan and was placed in charge of guarding the gunpowder beneath the House of Lords. During the night of November 4 and the early hours of November 5, 1605, he was discovered, and the conspiracy failed.
There is something important about this history that should not be overlooked. The conspirators were Catholics acting against a Protestant political establishment, but their plan was not a peaceful demand for religious liberty. They intended to kill the king and many others, then attempt to replace the existing political order. Their religious grievances formed part of the background, but those grievances do not, by themselves, justify the violence they planned.
What happened afterward creates another problem worth examining. The actions of a relatively small group intensified suspicion toward Catholics who had nothing to do with the conspiracy. King James himself recognized that most Catholics remained loyal, yet additional restrictions followed. In 1606, Parliament established an annual thanksgiving observance marking the king’s survival and the failure of the plot. Over time, the fifth of November became associated with bonfires, fireworks, and celebrations that also reflected anti-Catholic sentiment.
So when we remember November 5, what exactly are we remembering? Are we celebrating the survival of a king, the prevention of mass murder, or the preservation of a political and religious establishment? Those are not necessarily the same thing, and understanding the distinction matters when we consider what the date has come to symbolize through V for Vendetta.
When Religion and Political Power Become One
I have often wondered about people who argue that the United States should be a Christian nation because Christianity influenced its founding. When I hear that argument, I ask myself what the difference would be between a government that establishes Christianity as its preferred religious identity and one that establishes Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, or another religion in that position. I am not suggesting that all those religions, governments, or historical circumstances are identical. My concern is the principle being used to justify political authority.
If people believe their religion represents the truth, they have the freedom to practice it. They can worship, decline to participate in celebrations, and live according to their convictions, within the rights and laws applicable to everyone. But when they begin asking government to enforce those convictions upon others, we are no longer talking only about their individual freedom. We are talking about what happens to the people who do not believe as they do.
This is part of what I see in V for Vendetta. The Norsefire government uses fear, political authority, and a preferred moral order to control society. People who do not conform become threats simply because of their identities, convictions, or refusal to accept what the government expects of them. The film brings the danger of institutional power into focus, but the historical Gunpowder Plot reminds us that political and religious oppression existed long before anyone imagined V.
I encountered another example of this problem in a conversation with a coworker. He objected to the election of a Muslim because, in his reasoning, Muslims had killed Americans and Christians. I challenged him by pointing out that Christians have also killed Christians, and that people identifying as Christian have committed violence against Americans. When I mentioned Germany and the world wars, he rejected the comparison. He insisted that those people were not Christians, and when I brought up Catholics, he claimed that Catholics were not Christians.
Now, the world wars were not simply religious wars, and the religious identities of people who fought in them do not establish the causes of those conflicts. But that was not the point I was making to him. I was challenging the assumption that an entire religious population should be held responsible for the actions of some of its members, while another population is protected from the same judgment by deciding that the people who committed wrongdoing did not truly belong to the faith.
Not all Muslims are extremists, and not all Christians are extremists. That is what I was trying to explain. If we are going to condemn an individual’s actions, we should examine that individual’s actions rather than assume guilt because of a religious name. And if we are going to judge religious extremism, we should be willing to examine it even when it appears among people who share our own beliefs.
I am not Catholic, and I have my criticisms of the Catholic Church. Nevertheless, Catholicism is historically a branch of Christianity. The fact that another Christian tradition rejects Catholic teaching does not erase that classification. Religious identity becomes even more complicated when we consider communities such as Messianic Jews, whose beliefs and self-identification do not fit neatly into the categories other religious groups use for them.
What concerns me is how readily people can decide who belongs and who does not, sometimes without fully understanding the beliefs they are discussing. When those classifications remain matters of theological disagreement, people can debate them. But when they become the grounds for determining who deserves constitutional protection or political representation, the consequences extend beyond religious argument.
My own experience with Jehovah’s Witnesses helped shape how I understand this distinction. When I was younger, I strongly believed what I was being taught. At school, when other children celebrated birthdays, I did not participate. But I did not expect the entire class to abandon the celebration because of my beliefs, and I did not demand to stay home merely because the celebration was taking place.
The same principle applied when people celebrated Christmas or Halloween. I could decline to participate while recognizing that my friends had the freedom to celebrate. I was standing on my convictions without requiring everyone around me to adopt them. Later, as I began questioning the teachings I had accepted, my understanding changed. One of the difficulties I could no longer reconcile was the claim that a particular religious organization possessed the whole truth and that salvation was restricted to those within it.
I no longer identify with that religious tradition. But I also recognize that my decision does not give me authority over the convictions of someone who continues to believe. If I expect others to respect my freedom of conscience, I must examine whether I am willing to extend that same respect to them.
Machiavelli, V, and the Exercise of Power
There is another connection I see in V for Vendetta, and that is Niccolò Machiavelli. In The Prince, Machiavelli considers whether a ruler should be loved or feared. He argues that having both would be desirable, but if a ruler must choose, being feared is safer than depending entirely on the love of those he governs. Yet he also warns that the ruler should avoid becoming hated.
That qualification is important. There is a difference between having authority that people respect, being feared because one has the power to enforce laws, and becoming hated because that power is used against the people. A leader should understand the difference, especially when the decisions being made affect the liberties of an entire society.
In V for Vendetta, the government relies on fear to maintain control. It presents itself as the protector of society while determining which people and beliefs are acceptable. But fear can also undermine the authority it appears to protect. A population may obey because it is afraid without trusting the government or believing that its actions are justified.
V understands fear as well, although he uses it against the government rather than as a ruler seeking to preserve his position. He understands symbols, persuasion, and the effect that a carefully planned public act can have on people. That creates a problem I cannot ignore merely because I appreciate what V represents. If I question a government’s use of fear and coercion, I should also be willing to question those methods when they are used by someone resisting that government.
Machiavelli also wrote The Life of Castruccio Castracani, which contains a story that reminds me of V. In Machiavelli’s literary account, Dianora, the sister of a priest named Antonio, discovers an abandoned baby. The child is raised with the expectation that he might enter religious life, but he develops an interest in warfare and becomes a formidable military leader. The account of his discovery is a literary invention, not an established historical fact about Castruccio’s childhood.
I see a comparison in the development of a person whose life takes a direction that the circumstances of his beginning did not seem to predict. V is also shaped by what happens to him, but the comparison does not make their beliefs, objectives, or actions identical. More importantly, neither a difficult beginning nor exceptional ability makes every later decision morally correct.
This brings me back to leadership. I have often questioned how we select the people who govern us. We can become so impressed by popularity, persuasive language, and political slogans that we fail to examine a person’s actual record of leadership. What have they done? How have they led? Do they understand the complexity of the systems they want to govern? Those questions matter more to me than whether someone says what I want to hear.
The same examination should apply to someone who presents himself as a revolutionary. Being opposed to an oppressive government does not automatically establish that a person is qualified to replace it or that every method of resistance is justified. The purpose of challenging authority should not exempt the challenger from questions about authority.
Liberty of the Mind and Soul
I have said that V and I have a lot in common and nothing in common. Our views may not align on everything, and I do not claim that I would make the same decisions he makes. But I recognize something in his defense of the liberty of the mind and soul, or spirit.
For me, that liberty includes the right to think independently, to question what I have been taught, and to live within society without being forced to adopt the identity preferred by a political or religious institution. It includes freedom of speech, freedom of religion, and freedom to understand one’s own sexual, spiritual, and political identity. Those freedoms must exist alongside laws that apply to all members of society, not only those who share the beliefs of the people currently in power.
I believe in individual liberty, but I also recognize that society requires laws, civic ethics, and responsibilities. Smaller government does not mean that people should be free to harm others or that every institution should disappear. It means asking whether the government is protecting people’s rights or unnecessarily restricting them. It also means examining what government should do, what the private sector can do, and how either can be held accountable for its actions.
That examination cannot stop at the point where an answer becomes convenient. I have questioned my own beliefs, including religious convictions I once held strongly, and I expect my understanding to continue changing as I learn. If I establish a way of reasoning that cannot itself be questioned, then I have created another authority over my thinking rather than a means of developing it.
Political slogans present a similar danger. They can bring people together behind a few memorable words without requiring them to understand what those words mean or what the people repeating them intend to do. Even “Remember, remember the fifth of November” can become another slogan if we celebrate the mask without examining the history, the beliefs, and the actions behind it.
Remembering What We Are Willing to Lose
I want to honor V for Vendetta because it raises questions about freedom, oppression, and resistance that remain relevant beyond the fictional society it portrays. But celebrating V does not mean that I have to agree with everything he does, any more than defending religious freedom means agreeing with every religion.
The Gunpowder Plot began within a conflict where religious and political identities were inseparable from questions of power. Its failure prevented a planned mass killing, yet its aftermath also contributed to the mistreatment of people who had not participated in the conspiracy. The film uses that history to tell a different story about authority and resistance. Both invite examination, but neither should be reduced to the assumption that one side must be entirely righteous because the other has committed wrongdoing.
That is also why I continue returning to the difference between having convictions and imposing them. I should be free to practice my beliefs, and others should be free to practice theirs. If we disagree, the disagreement does not have to become a reason to deny one another the rights we expect for ourselves. I may be an idealist in expecting humanity to recognize that distinction more consistently, but I do not see why the expectation itself should be unreasonable.
The fifth of November has come to represent many things: a failed conspiracy, the survival of a government, a tradition of commemoration, and, through V for Vendetta, a symbol of resistance. For me, its significance reaches further into the liberty of the individual and the responsibility we carry when pursuing what we believe is right.
And that brings me back to a question I have been asking throughout this reflection.
What are we willing to lose for what we want to gain? And once we have gained it, was it worth losing what we gave up?
Remember, remember the fifth of November.
Historical and literary references
- UK Parliament, The Gunpowder Plot and its discovery
- UK Parliament, From Retribution to Toleration
- UK Parliament, Commemoration of the Gunpowder Plot
- The National Archives, The Gunpowder Plot
- Machiavelli, The Prince, Chapter XVII
- Machiavelli, The Life of Castruccio Castracani
- V for Vendetta (2006), directed by James McTeigue; screenplay by the Wachowskis.
Discover more from The Resilient Philosopher
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.